Module 1 · What is a CMH

What a CMH is for

A case management hearing is a short planning hearing held early in a claim. Nothing is decided about who is right. This lesson explains the four jobs the tribunal is trying to get done in it.

9 min videoLesson notesCMH preparation checklist

What you will be able to do after this lesson

  • Describe what happens at a case management hearing and what does not.
  • Name the four jobs the tribunal is trying to complete at the hearing.
  • Explain what a list of issues is and why the tribunal writes one.
  • Arrive at the hearing with the right papers and the right information to hand.

1.1 What the hearing is

A Case management hearing is a short hearing, usually early in a claim, where an Employment Judge works out with both sides how the case is going to run. It is often called a CMH. Nobody wins or loses anything at it, and nothing is decided about the facts.

The Employment Tribunal Procedure Rules 2024 give the tribunal a general power to make Case management orders, which are instructions about how a case is prepared and run. The 2024 Rules also allow the tribunal to hold a hearing for that purpose, so that it can go through the claim with both sides present before making those orders. That is the hearing you have been listed for.

1.2 What it looks like

  • Heard by a single Employment Judge, with no panel members.
  • Usually by video or telephone, though it can be in person.
  • Held in private, so there is no public gallery and no press.
  • Usually listed for somewhere between one and three hours, depending on the size of the case and how the tribunal region lists them.
  • No witnesses, no evidence, no cross-examination, and nothing for you to prove.

1.3 The four jobs

The first job is working out the issues. That means writing down the questions the final hearing will have to answer, rather than the story of what happened. In an unfair dismissal claim the questions might be whether there was a dismissal, what the reason for it was, and whether the employer acted reasonably in treating that reason as sufficient. The written version is called the List of issues, and once it exists it steers everything else.

The second job is the timetable. What documents each side has to hand over and by when, when the Bundle is put together, and when witness statements are written and exchanged. Each step gets a date.

The third job is the final hearing itself. How many days it needs, whether it will be in person or by video, and whether anyone needs an interpreter, breaks for a health condition, or any other adjustment. Leaving those things to the day does not work.

The fourth job is settlement. The tribunal will usually ask whether the case might resolve without a hearing, and may raise options such as Judicial mediation. Nobody is obliged to settle. The question simply gets asked.

Watch outThe list of issues is the part people skim. It is the part that decides what the final hearing is allowed to look at. If a complaint does not appear on it, there is a real risk it never gets decided, and adding it later means asking the tribunal for permission.

1.4 What to have ready

  • Your claim form and the response, read again recently rather than filed away since the day they were sent.
  • A two-sentence answer to the question, what is this claim about.
  • Any orders or agenda form the tribunal has already sent you.
  • Dates that will not work: holidays, treatment, caring responsibilities, shift patterns.
  • A rough idea of who your witnesses would be and what documents you think exist.

You are not there to argue your case, and nobody is persuaded of anything on the day. Being organised is what makes the difference.

That was lesson one

Case Management Hearings Made Simple

Five modules covering the whole hearing, from the letter landing on your mat to the order arriving afterwards. The AGENDA method, lesson notes you can print, and a check at the end of every module.

See what is in the course

This course explains how the Employment Tribunal works in general terms. It is not advice about your own case, and no barrister and client relationship is created by taking it. For advice on your own facts, see the services page or contact chambers.